First Pressings vs. Reissues: What Record Sellers Need to Know

If you’ve ever dusted off your vinyl collection and wondered, “Are these worth anything?”—you’re not alone.

At DJ Records™, we speak with sellers daily who are curious about the value of their records. One of the most common questions is about first pressings versus reissues. What’s the difference, and why does it matter when considering selling your vinyl collection?

Call (888) 993-4673

What Is a First Pressing?

A first pressing refers to the initial batch of records produced when an album is released. These records often come from the initial run of vinyl pressed directly from the original master recordings. For collectors and buyers, first pressings typically hold greater historical significance and are often considered more valuable, as they represent the album as it was initially introduced to the world.

  • Original Release Date: Pressed around the time the album was first launched.
  • Original Labels and Logos: They often feature period-specific label designs, logos, and text that may change in later pressings.
  • Country of Origin: Many collectors seek first pressings from the artist’s home country (for example, UK pressings of The Beatles albums).
  • Heavier Vinyl: Some early pressings were made with thicker vinyl than later versions.
  • Matrix/Runout Numbers: These are found in the dead wax (the blank space near the label) and can give clues about whether your record is a first pressing.

Why First Pressings Matter

Collectors are often after authenticity and originality. A first pressing may capture the sound as intended, and for many, there’s an emotional connection to owning a piece of music history. Because of their rarity, first pressings often command higher prices in the collector’s market.


What Is a Reissue?

A reissue is a later pressing of an album that was previously released. Record labels may reissue albums for various reasons, such as anniversaries, remastered versions, or to make older albums available again. Reissues can be produced years—or even decades—after the original release.

  • Updated Label Info: Reissues often have modern label designs, barcodes, and updated copyright information.
  • Different Mastering: Some are remastered for improved sound quality or even pressed on colored vinyl as a collector’s item.
  • Limited Editions: Some reissues are marketed as limited runs, which can be collectible in their own right.
  • Barcodes: Many reissues have barcodes on the cover, which wasn’t standard on albums from earlier decades.

Why Reissues Are Different

Reissues can be great for listening purposes and may still have value, but they typically aren’t as sought after by collectors as first pressings. This is primarily because they lack the historical authenticity and rarity that drive demand (and prices) for original releases.

Why This Difference Matters When You’re Selling Records

At DJ Records™, we specialize in buying entire vinyl collections from sellers across the United States. Whether you’re sitting on a few boxes of classic rock, jazz, soul, punk, or something more niche, knowing whether you have first pressings or reissues can make a big difference in our offer.

First Pressings Often Hold More Value

When we appraise a vinyl collection, first pressings catch our attention. Depending on the artist, genre, and condition, they can add significant value to a collection. For example, a first pressing of a highly sought-after album by an artist like Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, or The Rolling Stones can command higher prices than a reissue of the same album.

Reissues Are Still Valuable—But It Depends

Reissues can still retain value, especially those that are limited or part of special editions. However, common reissues pressed in large quantities are generally more available on the market, which can reduce their resale appeal.

Not Sure What You Have? That’s Where We Come In.

We understand that not everyone is a vinyl expert. You don’t have to be. At DJ Records™, we bring decades of experience in vinyl grading and evaluation to every collection we evaluate. If you’re unsure whether your records are first pressings, reissues, or something else entirely, we’re here to help you figure it out.

Our team travels nationwide, offering in-person evaluations and competitive offers for collections of all sizes. We buy records—plain and simple. We’re not resellers, consigners, or a marketplace where you list one record at a time. We make it easy for you to sell your entire collection seamlessly.

Ready to Sell? Let’s Talk.

If you’re thinking about selling your vinyl records and want an expert review, contact DJ Records™ today. Whether your collection includes rare first pressings or more recent reissues, we’ll give it the attention it deserves.

Contact us for a complimentary consultation and discover why collectors nationwide trust DJ Records to buy their vinyl collections.

WE BUY OLD RECORDS!

We’ve been buying LPs, 45s, 78s & 12″ singles for well OVER 20 YEARS.
No collection is too large!

Call (888) 993-4673
Excellent
DJ Records
Based on 39 reviews
I searched and struggled for quite a while to find a way to pass along my vinyl collection until I found DJ Records. Everything from first contact until Christian boxed up my collection was fair, hassle free and enjoyable. Thank you!
I have had 4 experiences with DJ Records in the past 12 months. Jeremy has been wonderful to deal with and the price I got was so much more then I was offered for a local company. They were a pleasure to deal with.
My brother left me his 65 year old record collection in his Will. I had no idea where to start. DJ Records worked with me to navigate the daunting task of partial liquidation. Great staff. Great experience!
While it may be disappointing to find out your coveted collections aren't as valuable as you thought, DJ Records made a fair deal for what was worth something. After doing much research into selling records on my own, I found that it would be a grueling task to try and sell over 800 records (if you look at the process : you have to mint, clean them up, take pictures, get them online, figure out how to ship, wait for the right buyer). The owner Ron arrived on time, during impending snow and carefully sorted thru each record. He made an offer same day and took all of the records immediately following. I was completely satisfied with the offer knowing I could not have done it on my own.
DJ Records were great .
They were very fair and wonderful to deal with